Surrogacy in US and Trump II

January 21, 2025
US Passport

President Trump was inaugurated yesterday, 20 January 2025, for his second non-consecutive term and in a sweep of executive orders he also revoked birthright citizenship for future-born children of anyone whose parents do not have settled immigration rights, i.e. are in the US illegally or only as visitors. Does this affect children born to foreign intended parents in US surrogacy?

What does the order say?

The right of people born on US soil to US citizenship is found in the Fourteenth Amendment to the US constitution. Trump’s order seems to hang on the meaning of “subject to the jurisdiction” of the US. Trump tries to exclude two categories of persons:

“(1) when that person’s mother was unlawfully present in the United States and the person’s father was not a United States citizen or lawful permanent resident at the time of said person’s birth,” and
“(2) when that person’s mother’s presence in the United States was lawful but temporary, and the person’s father was not a United States citizen or lawful permanent resident at the time of said person’s birth.”

This would, therefore, mean that children born to parents who are in the US as visitors (as most intended parents are) are excluded from citizenship.

However, the definitions may help IPs because:

“(a) “Mother” means the immediate female biological progenitor.
(b) “Father” means the immediate male biological progenitor.”

This while the surrogate may not be the legal mother due to a pre-birth or post-birth order, she might still be classed as the mother under the order. The definition is not clear because most children born to surrogates have an egg-donor and a surrogate, thus two female progenitors. Could “immediate” refer to the surrogate and exclude the egg-donor? This would in particular be important if the foreign intended mother’s eggs are used in the surrogacy.

Will this order hold up?

The order has been made and is likely to be challenged in the courts. The US Supreme Court seems to have decided the issue as long ago as 1898 in a case called United States v. Wong Kim Ark where a man born in San Francisco to Chinese immigrants was held to be a US Citizen. The court held that “subject to the jurisdiction” excluded only those who were born to foreign rulers or diplomats, born on foreign public ships, or born to enemy forces engaged in hostile occupation of the country’s territory (as well as native tribes, which was later dealt with by legislation).

What should IPs do?

The order takes effect for births 30 days after it was made, so 19 February 2025. Some precautions are probably wise, including:

  • Getting confirmation of the surrogate’s citizenship including a certified copy of her passport or other proof of citizenship;
  • Including in the contract with the surrogate that she confirms her citizenship and will cooperate with any requirements by authorities to prove that so that the IPs can apply for US citizenship for the child;
  • Including a similar clause in the egg-donor agreement in case “immediate female biological progenitor” is given a wider interpretation;
  • Obtaining proof that the surrogate gave birth and is therefore the “immediate female biological progenitor”, such as hospital records;
  • Asking the US passport office local to the place of birth in advance what evidence they may require, e.g. from the surrogate;
  • Get advice from your US attorney and see if the pre- or post-birth order should be re-worded to include that for the purposes of any application for US citizenship the surrogate is declared as the “immediate female biological progenitor”.

More will be known in weeks to come. In the meantime, advice from a specialist US attorney is vital.

Beware of Murky Surrogacy Arrangements

November 20, 2024

A gay couple living in England had engaged “SurrogateBaby” as an agency to have a child through surrogacy. According to the English judge, Mrs Justice Theis, they had at best been naïve about the process. The contract for this international surrogacy was unclear in a lot of areas and they were lucky to have avoided a total disaster. They could have got stuck in a third country with their baby daughter, being bankrupted by neonatal medical bills or worse not been able to have her at all.

While the judgment was almost entirely anonymised, it did name the agency. This agency has a live website and social media presence. It seems to be run by a Russian man and from the judgement the surrogate came from and lived during the surrogacy in a country where “due to the ongoing war” she could not deliver the baby in 2023. This is likely to have been Ukraine or Russia. She then gave birth in a third country and the intended parents were charged extra for this. Surrogacy for same-sex couples is illegal in that country. “SurrogateBaby” is now located in Georgia and this country would fit the description. The fertility treatment took place in the (internationally unrecognised territory of the) Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, which is not part of the EU (contrary to the Southern, Greek part of Cyprus).

The added complication in this particular case was that neither of the intended fathers was a British Citizen. They were both citizens of two different countries where homosexuality was illegal.

They contacted “SurrogateBaby” who told them they were based in “Cyprus”, but it later turned out their head office was elsewhere. The contract provided that the “carrying and childbirth will be carried out in a European Union (EU) country” (northern Cyprus is not an EU country). There is no indication that the country where the surrogate ultimately gave birth in was an EU country. Neither Ukraine nor Russia is in the EU. Even this would not have helped the intended fathers because the laws in the EU about surrogacy vary from full criminalisation (Italy), via situations where there is no criminal sanction for intended parents (Germany) to those where at least altruistic surrogacy is legal in certain circumstances (Netherlands, Denmark). Nor does a birth in the EU make travel to the UK any easier. Health coverage might possibly be under the NHS GHIC scheme in the EU, but it would make no difference to travel.

In the event, the intended fathers were told that the surrogate was to give birth in yet another country where gay couples were not recognised as fathers under surrogacy and so one of them had to pretend he had had a child with his girlfriend. He then had to apply for a passport from his country of origin (where homosexuality is illegal) for his daughter, travel there with her and apply for a UK visa from there for his daughter before being able to come to the UK half a year later. It turned out the surrogate had had no idea she was carrying for a gay couple, but was supportive and agreed to a parental order. The court considered the parental order application, which was granted.

This case shows that intended parents should always conduct due diligence on the proposed surrogacy, especially if it is not clear which countries are involved. In this case there were at least six different jurisdictions:

  1. The first intended father’s home country, where homosexuality is illegal.
  2. The second intended father’s home country, where homosexuality is illegal.
  3. The UK where they applied for a parental order, but where neither was a citizen.
  4. The surrogate’s home country (and the country where the address of the surrogacy agency “SurrogateBaby” was, where surrogacy for gay couples was illegal.
  5. Northern Cyprus, an unrecognised country outside the EU, where the fertility treatment took place.
  6. The country where the surrogate gave birth, where surrogacy for gay couples is illegal.

    The fathers should have made enquiries and obtained legal advice before embarking on this surrogacy journey to find out the legal situation in each of these countries. A lot more than did go wrong could have gone wrong in this case, for example:

    • The surrogate may have given birth in her home country prematurely. Neither the legal situation for the baby’s parentage nor the question of health cover for the baby are clear and the fathers may have had to fund neonatal intensive care out of their own pockets.
    • The baby may have required expensive hospital care in the country she was ultimately born in. Nothing was said or clear about how that would be funded and the fathers could have been stuck with a hefty bill.
    • The home country of the genetic father may not have provided him with a passport for his daughter, in particular if they found out he was gay. This could have meant that the baby would have been stuck in the country of her birth.
    • The father’s home country could have arrested him for his homosexuality while he was there with his daughter and taken her in to care with no other parent in the country.
    • The English court might not have granted the parental order application if they thought the fathers had not acted in good faith. In this case the judge had some doubts, but did make the order in the end. If she had decided otherwise, the second father’s relationship with his daughter would not have been recognised.
    • The surrogate may not have agreed to all or some of these arrangements. We know she was not told that she was carrying for a gay couple. The intended parents had no guarantee she was consenting to any of the arrangement. They had not met her and had no direct contract with her. There could have been criminal charges for trafficking because she was brought across international borders for the fertility treatment and to give birth.

    Overall, this case should be a warning to any intended parents to do their homework. If the offer looks too good to be true, it probably is.

    The case is reported here: Re Z [2024] EWFC 304

    Lesbian Couple’s Children in a Gulf State Subject to English Court

    February 23, 2024

    A recent case (S (Children: Parentage and Jurisdiction) [2023] EWCA Civ 897) shows two interesting points, which are of far wider significance on lesbian paternity and international family law.

    Two women had been civil partners in England and one of them gave birth to (it seems) four children. When the relationship broke down, the gestational mother moved to a Gulf State, they dissolved their civil partnership and both married other women. First the non-birth mother saw the children regularly, but the gestational mother then seems to have stopped that. The oldest child was in boarding school in England.

    Two questions were decided by the Court of Appeal:

    1. Were both women legal parents of the children?
    2. Could the English Court decide on issues child arrangements?

    While the oldest child had been born before a law change, the younger children were born after the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 s. 42 came into force, which provides:

    (1) If at the time of the placing in her of the embryo or the sperm and eggs or of her artificial insemination, W was a party to a civil partnership with another woman or a marriage with another woman, then […] the other party to the civil partnership or marriage is to be treated as a parent of the child unless it is shown that she did not consent to the placing in W of the embryo or the sperm and eggs or to her artificial insemination (as the case may be).

    Persian Gulf State - Scene in Dubai as Illustration

    The appeal court decided that consent did not have to be a “deliberate exercise of choice”, but rather the presence or absence of consent may be inferred from the circumstances. Consent does not have to be “in writing or oral or unarticulated” and while “acquiescence …is not the same thing as consent”, “but the court will be careful to distinguish acquiescence from consent that has not been expressly stated.”

    “The big picture here was that these were parties to a civil partnership who wanted children and created a family”; the court had accepted that the non-birth mother wanted children and “The judge’s conclusion that [the non-birth mother] merely acquiesced sits uneasily in the context of a relationship between cohabiting civil partners.”

    This is significant as it gives more certainty to same-sex families and their children. The norm in cohabiting married couples or civil partners must be that if one of the women has a child, the other one is a legal parent of the child.

    The second issue was whether the English Court could decide on the issues about the children. In this case the Gulf State in which (at least) the younger children lived did not recognise same-sex relationships and did not recognise parental rights of non-birth mothers. So they would not decide on any application by the non-birth mother for time with the children. The basic rule is that the courts where the children live have the power to make such decisions. This is also the basis in the 1996 Hague Convention. However, if no country has jurisdiction under those rules, the English court also have the power to make decisions in connection with continuing divorce and civil partnership dissolution proceedings in England. The question was whether this applied in the case where the civil partnership dissolution had been concluded more than 5 years earlier.

    The court followed another recent case (Re T (Children) (Jurisdiction: Matrimonial Proceedings) [2023] EWCA Civ 285) and found that the English courts can continue to decide on child arrangements until they are 18 if the divorce or civil partnership dissolution as in England and Wales. This allows the English courts to look at child arrangements where the divorce or civil partnership dissolution was in England provided the country where the children live (broadly) is not a member of the 1996 Hague Convention. In cases where this could happen, that may be a good reason to have the divorce in England rather than elsewhere.

    The practical effect for this non-birth mother is not entirely clear from the report. I suppose with the oldest son in boarding school in England the birth mother continues to travel to England and does not want to fall foul of a court order so will comply with an order made in England.

    Relocation Applications After Brexit

    July 20, 2016

    The UK and in particular London has an international and cosmopolitan population, with many bi-national couples, not least due to free movement of citizens in the EU. On separation and divorce issues sometimes arise when one parent wants to move back to their home country with the child and the other parent does not agree. In those cases the court will need to decide on the relocation application, often called leave to remove the child out of the jurisdiction.

    European_union_flag-2I have had enquiries in recent weeks from parents who are thinking over their future and their children’s futures after the Brexit referendum outcome in June 2016. Some wonder how long they can stay living in England and Wales and want to move now because they fear they may have to leave in a couple of years. Others want to move abroad with their children now, so that their children can experience an international upbringing while this is still possible in the EU.

    Most strikingly, Sterling dropped against the Euro by 20% as against the exchange rate at the end of 2015. The effect on property prices in the UK remains to be seen. There are issues which can make practical arrangement in relocation cases easier or more difficult as a result of the referendum outcome and, if and when it happens, Brexit, including:

    • The Sterling fares for flights and Eurostar trips are likely to increase, either because the company bases their fares in Euros and/or because fuel is based in US Dollar.
    • Buying property in Europe will be more expensive for UK migrants as a result of the drop in Sterling.
    • Maintenance payments for children paid from the UK will not go as far in Europe as they used to only a few weeks ago.
    • It may not be clear if British Citizens will be able to stay abroad post-Brexit and if so in what circumstances. Equally, EU citizens in Britain may not be able to stay here and should consider their situation now – either by applying for permanent residence and/or citizenship or by considering when is the best time for their child to move countries.
    • UK citizens and EU citizens moving back to their own country may not be able to use the EHIC card to obtain free or subsidised health care abroad and may need to take out private health insurance from the start post-Brexit, something that makes emigrating to the US expensive.

    So while there are a lot of uncertainties and issues to come if and when the UK leaves the EU, some parents may want to consider their situation now and obtain legal advice to find the best way to face what may happen head on.

    Brexit and Family Law

    July 8, 2016

    As I’m sitting on a Eurostar train to Brussels, this is a good time to reflect on what Brexit means for family law in England. It is of course important to bear in mind that until the UK actually leaves the EU, all EU law continues to apply in full and even after that, all or some may apply.

    There are two main pieces of EU law which are important for family law:

    20151226_075810Brussels II: This regulation provides where you can start a divorce in the EU and where you can start proceedings about children. Wherever you have started a court case first, it stays there. So there can be a race to the court. Since English courts apply English law to divorce and financial matters and also to cases about arrangements for children, the outcome of a case in the courts in England can be very different to the outcome in another country. Don’t forget though that the other country may well apply English law to all or some of the aspects of the case. So for example in a recent case the couple are both German and live in England. The husband started a divorce in Germany and the German court applies English law to the divorce itself and also to child and spouse maintenance, but not to the sharing of assets. You need specialist advice on these matters from both (or all) possible countries where a divorce could be started.

    For child arrangements the courts of the country where the child is habitually resident usually have jurisdiction. It also makes some additional provisions to strengthen the Hague Convention on Child Abduction for the EU, such as targets to deal with cases in a certain time.

    After Brexit, the UK might enter into a treaty with the EU to continue the provisions of Brussels II or it might not. My guess is that it would not want to be seen as a friend of child abductors, so the pressure to enter into an agreement that apply the provisions on children cases to the UK is strong. It is not so strong on the divorce side.

    Maintenance: The EU provisions for maintenance regulate where you can start a case and once you have a judgment how to enforce it in another EU country. There is already a treaty to apply very similar provisions to Switzerland, Iceland and Norway, the Lugano Treaty. So on this one, my guess is that Britain might simply become a signatory to the Lugano treaty too.

    Aside from the law, and whether or not Brexit is ultimately going to happen, the immediate effect is that we cannot be certain about house prices and that Sterling has seen a drastic drop. So in any financial cases where there are assets in several countries, the comparison of the valuations is going to be difficult: If the parties (and the court) think that the exchange rates are going to recover in the medium to long term, they could take historic exchange rates from earlier in 2016. Unfortunately, since one exchange rate is going to favour one party and another the other party, this could all become contentious. This does, of course, not only affect the Sterling-Euro exchange rate, which was at €1.50 at the end of 2015 and now is below €1.20, a 20% drop, but also the Sterling-US-Dollar exchange rate and any other currency linked to the dollar or Euro in some way. Some parties might want to put financial negotiations on hold until there is certainty.

    Where there are assets such as real property or shares where a current valuation is impossible to obtain, it might also be wise to wait unless it is clear an asset will be sold and the proceeds be shared equally. In that case it is just a matter for the parties to agree on the time of sale.

    by Andrea Woelke

    EU-Certificate for Divorce in England

    July 1, 2016

    A post in an online forum for Germans in London recently asked how to get the EU-Form after a divorce in England which the German authorities require. The poster was puzzled, as were the courts. Most family courts do not know about this, but can find out and will get the form signed by a judge and sealed if you fill it in.

    The EU-Regulation about divorce jurisdiction and recognition, Regulation 2201/2003 has several forms in the Annexes, which – as the whole regulation – are of course available in all official EU languages. The idea is that you get a form sealed in one EU member state and anyone can then retrieve an empty form in their language, lay them side-by-side and check what each of the points say about the parties, date of divorce etc.

    In England once you have a decree absolute, you will need to get the relevant form, which you can download and then send it to the family court where your divorce was pronounced and ask them to get it signed by a judge and sealed. I’d suggest to get at least 3 copies because you might need them for various official business. It is free and easy to get immediately after your divorce. It could be a lot more complicated when you need it 10 years later.

    by Andrea Woelke