Conduct and Domestic Abuse

August 23, 2024

One of the factors the court must consider in financial proceedings after divorce or civil partnership dissolution is:

“the conduct of each of the parties, if that conduct is such that it would in the opinion of the court be inequitable to disregard it;” (s.25(2)(g) Matrimonial Causes Act 1973).

Often parties feel aggrieved about the behaviour of their spouse at the time of the breakdown of the marriage. Perhaps the relationship has been fraught and toxic for a while. A party may feel that they were trapped in this relationship and could not get out. Others may blame their spouse on the breakdown of the marriage and blame it on the other’s infidelity or accuse them of having walked out on them and the children. It is then tempting to tell the court that the other party’s conduct should be taken into account. However, this can be dangerous and even backfire!

The statutory definition in s.25 seems circuitous. So, when is conduct such that it would be inequitable to disregard it. There is no clear definition in case law either. Conduct must be “both obvious and gross” (“gross” as in severe rather than disgusting). Well, what does that mean? From decided cases we can see that there are broadly three categories, although any particular behaviour may also fall into more than one category:

  • Marital conduct
  • Financial conduct
  • Litigation conduct

Examples for marital conduct are where one spouse tried to kill the other, paid third parties to attempt to kill their spouse, the husband had raped and assaulted the wife or ongoing child abduction. There usually needs to be a financial consequence of the conduct for it to make a difference. For example, the mother of the abducted children was given money to pay for legal fees so she could try to get the children back to England.

Financial conduct cases include those where a spouse syphoned off large amounts of money and hid them, transferred a family business into a company in their own name or deceived the spouse or their family over a long period to pay money to a lover.

Litigation conduct includes deceiving the court and hiding assets at the time of the financial court proceedings. It could also include running a case which has no hope of success just to achieve that the spouse runs out of money to pay their lawyers and gives up. Thus, in extreme cases pleading a hopeless marital conduct case could amount to litigation conduct. Often the consequence is that the court will make a costs order against that party, which could amount to a substantial sum or even eat up most of what that party ends up with from the division of the assets.

From this it is also clear that many examples of behaviour will not amount to conduct, including:

  • Having an affair;
  • Spending money on items that are morally wrong unless this is on an extremely large scale;
  • Addiction including alcohol or gambling, unless perhaps someone gambled away the house and the only item left is the pension, which might then go to the other spouse;
  • Being mean, cruel or lying in general.

The question is how the definition of domestic abuse from the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 makes a difference to this. Under the definition domestic abuse also includes

  • controlling or coercive behaviour,
  • psychological, emotional or other abuse and
  • economic abuse.

“’Economic abuse’ means any behaviour that has a substantial adverse effect on B’s ability to—
(a) acquire, use or maintain money or other property, or
(b) obtain goods or services.”

My guess is that here the courts will also require a case to be severe. As in physical abuse the examples where conduct was successfully pleaded amount to attempted murder or similar, non-physical abuse will need to be severe, prolonged and have a substantial financial consequence.

Thus gaslighting the wife, belittling her, making her cut off her family and friends alone may not be conduct. However, I could see a case where that resulted in her giving up her career so that now at the time of her divorce this has severely affected her ability to generate enough income to pay for her financial needs and build up a pension. I could see a court making an order, for example, for ongoing maintenance or a more than 50% pension share where it would not otherwise have done so. A direct financial consequence is not doubt very helpful, although an extreme case of PTSD resulting in an inability to work substantially might also succeed.

Unless there is a financial detriment which can be shown to result from the abuse, I would be cautious about running a conduct argument in these circumstances because doing so runs the risk of the court making an order for costs against the party who pleaded conduct if it finds against them.

As with all non-physical abuse there is also an evidential issue: How does one prove the abuse, especially if it is not recent but behaviour over money years?

Qualified Legal Representatives

February 26, 2024

The law recognises that victims of domestic abuse could be retraumatised if they were to be cross-examined by their abusers who are representing themselves. The law now provides for the court to appoint a lawyer to do so instead: a “Qualified Legal Representative” (QLR).

Royal Courts of Justice in London

The (alleged) abuser must of course also have a fair hearing, whether in the proceedings about an order preventing them from continuing or repeating the abuse or in financial or children proceedings. To deal with this conundrum, the court will now order for a QLR to conduct the cross-examination of the other party instead in cases where (alleged) abusers are “Litigants in Person”, that means representing themselves. QLRs are paid by the government (although not generously) and are family solicitors or barristers. They are there solely to cross-examine the other party and will not represent the (alleged) abuser otherwise. The court may ask them to provide a written summary of the case for the court hearing, but after they have done their cross-examination they leave and the (alleged) abusers will then continue to represent themselves.

Cross-examination is still tough or any witness, let alone a victim of domestic abuse, in particular if the case is about the abuse. However, the QLR is specially trained to (cross-)examine vulnerably witnesses and the victim is not asked direct questions from the abuser. That must take some strain out of that otherwise unpleasant experience.

For the (alleged) abuser, while not getting their own lawyer to represent them, they are being helped by an advocate with what is probably the most difficult task of a final hearing, namely cross-examination. That should also help them to an extend to summarise their case for the court.

The Archers – Protecting Helen Titchener

July 6, 2016

As an avid listener of the Archers I have been fascinated by the storyline of the marriage between Rob and Helen. Rob’s abuse of Helen has now culminated in a bloodbath and criminal prosecution.The topic of today’s post is, however, what Helen could have done to protect herself before it came to this.

Storyline summary:

Helen Titchener (née Archer), the daughter of Pat and Tony, was suffering from anorexia when younger and was in a relationship with the former game keeper who then took his own life. She decided she wanted a child when she did not have a partner and had Henry (now 5) by IVF. She formed a relationship with Rob Titchener, who was working at the estate farm and was then still married. He divorced his wife and married Helen, to the astonishment of her family. Rob seems charming and takes everyone in. Over the last year or so, the listener witnessed how he became more and more controlling of Helen and was violent to her. He became ostensibly caring but even more controlling after she told him she was pregnant. He stopped her from working, then from driving, talked behind her back to destroy her friendship with Ian (casually told him that his husband had kissed a colleague and Helen knew), and Helen started doubting her own sanity. Eventually, she confided in her old friend Kirsty who gave Helen a spare mobile phone and put in a number of a domestic abuse helpline.

Helen decided to leave Rob and packed a bag. While cooking dinner in the kitchen, she told Rob and he took a knife and challenged her to kill him as this was the only way she would be able to get rid of him. He then seems to have run past her to get Henry and she took the knife and stabbed Rob.

Rob survived and Helen is now on remand for attempted murder. Henry was staying with Helen’s parents while Rob was in hospital, but Rob failed to return Henry after the first contact and there are now legal proceedings about where Henry should live, while Henry is living with Rob and only sees his maternal grandparents on Sundays. In the meantime Helen has given birth to a baby boy in a mother-and-baby unit of a prison who she has named Jack. Rob wants Jack to live with him (and has given him a different name). Helen has difficulties getting her own story together and giving her lawyers instructions.

IMG-20111001-00007hThe question for me while following the story was what Helen could have done if she had sought legal advice before she left Rob. This is tricky because Rob is good at lying, so good most people believe him and doubt their own senses and sanity. Even judges are regularly taken in by such people as the recent case of Ben Butler jailed for life for murdering his daughter shows. As for Helen Rob seems to have been “gaslighting” her. He seems to have deliberately filled Henry’s bath which Helen was running, with scolding water so that Helen would believe she was losing it, for example. If Helen had left, he would have almost certainly argued she was unfit to look after Helen (and later the then unborn child) and applied for them to live with him (as he is now doing). All the abuse was behind closed doors and it would have been Helen’s (very confused) word against Rob’s (convincing and clear) evidence.

If Helen had come to me I would have firstly considered her own and Henry’s safety, whether the risk to them was such that she had to leave immediately or whether perhaps she could stay to gather evidence. It might have been possible to leave Henry more and more with Helen’s parents using excuses and also get rid of Rob’s mother Ursula (who seems even more manipulative than Rob) by Helen pleading she needed a quiet house during the pregnancy. Helen should always have had an escape plan for immediate help including friends and family who could come and a way to dial 999 to call the police. Should could have talked to the police to make them aware of the situation anyway.

If the risk was too high, I would have advised Helen to leave straight away, but she would have had to be prepared for a lengthy and relentless legal battle over children issues and finances with Rob. She may have been able to mitigate this by going into a women’s refuge, but it is difficult to hide for ever and Rob would have no doubt made applications for contact with Henry, even though he is not his legal father (he apparently has parental responsibility).

If by using some safeguarding measures Helen could have stayed on for a bit, she could have considered how to ensure that there were independent witnesses to the abuse while not provoking Rob to have dangerous outbursts. This is a tricky strategy, but it may have worked. She could, for example, have asked Rob in the village shop for the car keys so other people independent of the family would have witnessed him refusing (or taken the keys so that he would have demanded them from her) etc. Rather than having oral evidence against each other, the only way to win a case against a convincing abuser like Rob is to have external hard evidence, written documents or entirely independent witnesses.

The other strategy, which incidentally Helen’s family should pursue now, is to delve deeper into Rob’s background and anything he did. This could include:
finding out why he suddenly left his job at the estate (he would have been sacked for misconduct) and once this was found out, get witness evidence from the colleagues and research into his previous employment too;

  • find the hunt protester he assaulted a year or so before and see if Shula Hebden-Lloyd will retract her evidence in favour of Rob Titchener which meant he was not charged for the assault (Shula should be aware she might risk a prosecution for perverting the cause of justice);
  • contact the boarding school Rob and Ursula visited and planned to send Henry to behind Helen’s back, check when they contacted the school and how they presented the plans, get this is all in writing and obtain witness statements from the head teacher or admissions officer;
  • contact Rob’s first wife to see if she will give evidence – this will be tainted as Rob will no doubt argue she is just trying to seek revenge – she might, however, have similar compelling independent evidence and could help with contacting previous employers;
  • Rob similarly tried to manipulate Tom, Helen’s brother, by making orders of stock for the farm shop behind his back etc. Tom could ensure that there is a paper (or email) trail for Rob’s behaviour there – again as family, this is not the best evidence;
  • talk to Henry’s school and get details of when exactly he was being difficult or had problems, see if that can be linked to particular behaviour of Rob.
    Overall this would have been a difficult case to put together. No doubt there would have been more examples in real life which one could have looked at. Helen’s and Henry’s safety should always have come first of course.

Clients often ask if they should film their partner so they have proof of the behaviour. The family courts hate this because it seems overly intrusive and harassing in itself. However, at times this might be the only way to have evidence of abuse. This is something Helen should have considered with her solicitor in great detail. If so, cameras could have been installed in the house without Rob noticing and the footage would only be used if absolutely necessary and after Helen was away and safe. This would have required considerable logistical planning.

Staying to gather evidence would have been a risky strategy, not least because Rob’s barrister would have cross-examined Helen and put it to her why she did not leave the abuse and exposed Henry to it if it was that bad. So protecting Henry and her must be the absolute priority in any event.

by Andrea Woelke

The Archers – Anna Tregorran the Lawyer

July 5, 2016

In last night’s Archers (4 July 2016) Anna Tregorran, the barrister representing Helen Titchener confessed to her mother that she was shaken by this case because in the past she failed to protect a client who was then killed by her abusive partner. This is unfortunately not fiction and does happen. It is good to show the human side to our work as family lawyers (even if there is some artistic licence in that there does not seem to be a solicitor), which can be tough going at times.

Unfortunately, abusive partners like Rob Titchener in the Archers sometimes tend to be extremely convincing witnesses and courts are fooled and believe their story instead of the victim’s account. The storyline is fascinating and has given me plenty of food for thought as well as recognition from cases I have dealt with over the years. The most frustrating thing is that here as in real life, we see people getting into a deeper mess because they fail to get legal advice or, when they do, do not act on it. So Pat Archer (Helen’s mother) was told not to talk to the police without consulting Helen’s lawyer. She went off and did and has now become a prosecution witness and must not talk to or even meet her own daughter.

Helen could have taken steps to protect herself and Henry much earlier, although it is often not clear if she would have been strong enough. I will write more about that some other time.

by Andrea Woelke