Conduct and Domestic Abuse
One of the factors the court must consider in financial proceedings after divorce or civil partnership dissolution is:
“the conduct of each of the parties, if that conduct is such that it would in the opinion of the court be inequitable to disregard it;” (s.25(2)(g) Matrimonial Causes Act 1973).
Often parties feel aggrieved about the behaviour of their spouse at the time of the breakdown of the marriage. Perhaps the relationship has been fraught and toxic for a while. A party may feel that they were trapped in this relationship and could not get out. Others may blame their spouse on the breakdown of the marriage and blame it on the other’s infidelity or accuse them of having walked out on them and the children. It is then tempting to tell the court that the other party’s conduct should be taken into account. However, this can be dangerous and even backfire!
The statutory definition in s.25 seems circuitous. So, when is conduct such that it would be inequitable to disregard it. There is no clear definition in case law either. Conduct must be “both obvious and gross” (“gross” as in severe rather than disgusting). Well, what does that mean? From decided cases we can see that there are broadly three categories, although any particular behaviour may also fall into more than one category:
- Marital conduct
- Financial conduct
- Litigation conduct
Examples for marital conduct are where one spouse tried to kill the other, paid third parties to attempt to kill their spouse, the husband had raped and assaulted the wife or ongoing child abduction. There usually needs to be a financial consequence of the conduct for it to make a difference. For example, the mother of the abducted children was given money to pay for legal fees so she could try to get the children back to England.
Financial conduct cases include those where a spouse syphoned off large amounts of money and hid them, transferred a family business into a company in their own name or deceived the spouse or their family over a long period to pay money to a lover.
Litigation conduct includes deceiving the court and hiding assets at the time of the financial court proceedings. It could also include running a case which has no hope of success just to achieve that the spouse runs out of money to pay their lawyers and gives up. Thus, in extreme cases pleading a hopeless marital conduct case could amount to litigation conduct. Often the consequence is that the court will make a costs order against that party, which could amount to a substantial sum or even eat up most of what that party ends up with from the division of the assets.
From this it is also clear that many examples of behaviour will not amount to conduct, including:
- Having an affair;
- Spending money on items that are morally wrong unless this is on an extremely large scale;
- Addiction including alcohol or gambling, unless perhaps someone gambled away the house and the only item left is the pension, which might then go to the other spouse;
- Being mean, cruel or lying in general.
The question is how the definition of domestic abuse from the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 makes a difference to this. Under the definition domestic abuse also includes
- controlling or coercive behaviour,
- psychological, emotional or other abuse and
- economic abuse.
“’Economic abuse’ means any behaviour that has a substantial adverse effect on B’s ability to—
(a) acquire, use or maintain money or other property, or
(b) obtain goods or services.”
My guess is that here the courts will also require a case to be severe. As in physical abuse the examples where conduct was successfully pleaded amount to attempted murder or similar, non-physical abuse will need to be severe, prolonged and have a substantial financial consequence.
Thus gaslighting the wife, belittling her, making her cut off her family and friends alone may not be conduct. However, I could see a case where that resulted in her giving up her career so that now at the time of her divorce this has severely affected her ability to generate enough income to pay for her financial needs and build up a pension. I could see a court making an order, for example, for ongoing maintenance or a more than 50% pension share where it would not otherwise have done so. A direct financial consequence is not doubt very helpful, although an extreme case of PTSD resulting in an inability to work substantially might also succeed.
Unless there is a financial detriment which can be shown to result from the abuse, I would be cautious about running a conduct argument in these circumstances because doing so runs the risk of the court making an order for costs against the party who pleaded conduct if it finds against them.
As with all non-physical abuse there is also an evidential issue: How does one prove the abuse, especially if it is not recent but behaviour over money years?
Posted in Finances | Tagged Abuse Divorce
Questionnaires in Financial Proceedings in Divorce or Civil Partnership Dissolution
I recently got asked about schedules of deficiencies and supplemental questionnaires by someone acting in person who had a long questionnaire to answer and was worried he had not asked enough questions himself.
I often see solicitors and barristers in financial cases drafting very extensive questionnaires including questions which are not necessary to decide the case. My view is that this is motivated by lawyers being over-cautious to protect themselves.
The questions should all be relevant to the issues, so it is best to look at and/or draft the Statement of Issues first. Questions could arise out of
- the Form E itself (when information is missing, such as a pension valuation) or
- arise later from a response to a question or from a reply to a question in the Form E, for example when a response to how much last year’s bonus was is that it came to (unexpectedly high) £50,000 and then the question arises what happened to the money.
The questions I come across can, perhaps, be put in 3 categories:
- Issues which the other person must know for their case, for example if the Form E simply says that someone has private pension, but no valuation is provided.
- Issues which the other person does not need to know but would like to know as it may help them to present the case, such as the income of the new partner when there is no suggestion that the new partner will pay maintenance or that the other person’s own income is insufficient to meet their own outgoings, or if the case is clearly not a maintenance case because both spouses have similar income. In this category are also questions which are there simply to retaliate, so it may be necessary to look at one party’s credit card statements to see how they have spent large amounts each month, while the other party’s spending is not in issue, but the question will find itself onto the other questionnaire, often as an addition on the day of the first directions appointment. These should not be allowed, but often unfortunately are.
- Issues which the questioner would rather remain obscured, such as if in the Form E someone says they owe £5,000 to their brother. In that case the other person may ask for proof to give the person alleging the debt the opportunity to provide that and if they do not, then they can ask the court to disregard the debt as at best a soft loan. They ask the question so that they can make the argument later on. This is legitimate.
Sometimes people ask questions which are:
- Issues for directions, such as the valuation of a property, for which the court usually directs that the parties either agree the value after getting estate agents appraisals or if they cannot agree, instruct an independent valuer.
- Issues for cross-examination, for example: “Why have you still not found a job when you had a year to find one?”
The court should disallow such questions, but often allows them. Nobody will get points at the final hearing for having asked more questions and the judge probably will not read the questions and answers, which are often then irrelevant or are at best difficult to follow. The judge would normally only look at a question and answer if an issue was not agreed.
If after the first appointment you think there are issues which you forgot to ask and could have asked, first check whether the court will need to know the answer to decide any of the issues, which the parties have identified in their statement of issues at the first appointment. If so, you should then consider if the answer is already there or if you can provide it in another way. For example, if a party claims that they cannot possibility find a suitable property in an area which is convenient for the children’s school for £100,000 less than the family home is now worth, you could do your own research and provide particulars of properties for the court. If you view them and see why they are suitable (and include perhaps a couple which are not), that shows you have researched this thoroughly. Rather than ambushing the other party at the final hearing, however, you should then send the particulars to them or their solicitor and ask them to agree that these properties are suitable and, if not, state why not and provide particulars of properties which are suitable.
If the issue is in category 3 above, that could also be addressed in correspondence with a clear warning that the letter will be referred to at the final hearing and that you will submit that the court should disregard the debt to the brother (or as the case may be) unless proof is provided of the terms etc.
You should only make an application to the court for permission to adduce further questions if you are confident that you can explain that they are absolutely vital. If that is the case, you should write to the other party’s solicitors first setting out the question or questions and why they are vital and ask for the question to be answered voluntarily. Set a deadline for them to confirm it will be answered (say 7 days) and for an answer (day 21 days) and state that you will be making an urgent application to the court if there is no positive response. You could then ask the court to consider the issue in writing and attach the correspondence.
Unfortunately each case is very different, so I cannot say what applies in any particular case without considering the documents and taking full instructions.
If you want to make an appointment, get in touch.
Posted in Finances | Tagged court procedure questionnaires