Heated and Long “Unreasonable Behaviour” Divorce Petitions
I saw a client the other day who came with a divorce petition his wife had issued against him after they had recently separated. This contained two pages of allegations of unreasonable behaviour. Leaving aside what if anything of this may have any basis in truth in the particular case, I was quite taken aback that the solicitor had even drafted and issued this petition on behalf of the wife. While I am not privy to the instructions of course, the particulars looked as if the solicitor had simply taken down what the wife had told them and copied it onto the divorce form.
Before going into detail it is important to go back to the law and remind ourselves that the fact is not “unreasonable behaviour”, but (as set out in section 1 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973) particulars showing:
“that the respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent”
So the behaviour itself does not need to be unreasonable at all. Reasonableness goes to the question of whether future cohabitation can be expected.
So this petitioner, which is not uncommon had a variety of allegations, including:
- Things the husband was supposed to have done 2 years ago or more. This is irrelevant. The behaviour alleged must be in the six months before separation or, if later, before the petition according to section 2(3).
- Justifications of the wife’s own behaviour. Again this is totally irrelevant.
- Issues which are not behaviour, such as communication problems between the parties, the relationship they had with their family etc.
- An extended narrative of the history of the marriage (moving house and jobs). A brief sentence may in some circumstances be needed to understand an allegation of behaviour, but anything more than that is probably superfluous.
- Allegations which are unspecific about when they occurred (“recently”). Even if exact dates are not known, it needs to be clear that this was within the six-month period (for example, “at some time in October 2014”).
With behaviour petitions as in so many other legal and non-legal contexts, quantity does not make up for lack of quality.
Nor do courts endorse parties slinging mud against each other. Contested divorces lead to a hearing in public. It rarely happens because the process is complicated and, if the parties are represented, costly. With more people representing themselves, it is likely that they are going to be more frequent. Courts try to discourage them, as in a recent case where a husband (an immigration solicitor it seems) insisted on divorcing his wife on quite salacious allegations including that she offered her services as a prostitute to women on the website Gumtree. If in this case the husband loses the case in the end, he may face having to pay his wife’s legal costs. The judge in the Court of Appeal, Lady Justice Black, pointed out that since they were separated for more than two years and both wanted a divorce, they could agree to withdraw the behaviour petitions and divorce on two years’ separation and consent.
Often clients are unsure what they can use as behaviour. Two points to bear in mind frequently lead to an easy solution:
- The behaviour does not need to be before the separation, it can be after the separation. Often one or both spouses have found a new partner, whether a serious relationship or on a more casual basis. The only question is whether the petitioner can reasonably be expected to live together in the future, not whether it was reasonable to separate at the time.
- Any intimate relationship which does not fall into the category of adultery can still be behaviour. This is also helpful for civil partnership dissolutions.
So one solution in many cases, which does not inevitably cause concern for the other spouse is to have a behaviour petition based on the other’s intimate relationship(s) with another man or woman (who does not need to be named) since separation. In fact it is not necessary to specify the gender of the person the respondent had an intimate relationship with.
For help with drafting a petition and divorce in general, please contact us.
Posted in Divorce