Questionnaires in Financial Proceedings in Divorce or Civil Partnership Dissolution

July 19, 2016

I recently got asked about schedules of deficiencies and supplemental questionnaires by someone acting in person who had a long questionnaire to answer and was worried he had not asked enough questions himself.

I often see solicitors and barristers in financial cases drafting very extensive questionnaires including questions which are not necessary to decide the case. My view is that this is motivated by lawyers being over-cautious to protect themselves.

The questions should all be relevant to the issues, so it is best to look at and/or draft the Statement of Issues first. Questions could arise out of

  1. the Form E itself (when information is missing, such as a pension valuation) or
  2. arise later from a response to a question or from a reply to a question in the Form E, for example when a response to how much last year’s bonus was is that it came to (unexpectedly high) £50,000 and then the question arises what happened to the money.

The questions I come across can, perhaps, be put in 3 categories:

  1. Issues which the other person must know for their case, for example if the Form E simply says that someone has private pension, but no valuation is provided.
  2. Issues which the other person does not need to know but would like to know as it may help them to present the case, such as the income of the new partner when there is no suggestion that the new partner will pay maintenance or that the other person’s own income is insufficient to meet their own outgoings, or if the case is clearly not a maintenance case because both spouses have similar income. In this category are also questions which are there simply to retaliate, so it may be necessary to look at one party’s credit card statements to see how they have spent large amounts each month, while the other party’s spending is not in issue, but the question will find itself onto the other questionnaire, often as an addition on the day of the first directions appointment. These should not be allowed, but often unfortunately are.
  3. Issues which the questioner would rather remain obscured, such as if in the Form E someone says they owe £5,000 to their brother. In that case the other person may ask for proof to give the person alleging the debt the opportunity to provide that and if they do not, then they can ask the court to disregard the debt as at best a soft loan. They ask the question so that they can make the argument later on. This is legitimate.

Sometimes people ask questions which are:

  1. Issues for directions, such as the valuation of a property, for which the court usually directs that the parties either agree the value after getting estate agents appraisals or if they cannot agree, instruct an independent valuer.
  2. Issues for cross-examination, for example: “Why have you still not found a job when you had a year to find one?”

The court should disallow such questions, but often allows them. Nobody will get points at the final hearing for having asked more questions and the judge probably will not read the questions and answers, which are often then irrelevant or are at best difficult to follow. The judge would normally only look at a question and answer if an issue was not agreed.

If after the first appointment you think there are issues which you forgot to ask and could have asked, first check whether the court will need to know the answer to decide any of the issues, which the parties have identified in their statement of issues at the first appointment. If so, you should then consider if the answer is already there or if you can provide it in another way. For example, if a party claims that they cannot possibility find a suitable property in an area which is convenient for the children’s school for £100,000 less than the family home is now worth, you could do your own research and provide particulars of properties for the court. If you view them and see why they are suitable (and include perhaps a couple which are not), that shows you have researched this thoroughly. Rather than ambushing the other party at the final hearing, however, you should then send the particulars to them or their solicitor and ask them to agree that these properties are suitable and, if not, state why not and provide particulars of properties which are suitable.

If the issue is in category 3 above, that could also be addressed in correspondence with a clear warning that the letter will be referred to at the final hearing and that you will submit that the court should disregard the debt to the brother (or as the case may be) unless proof is provided of the terms etc.

You should only make an application to the court for permission to adduce further questions if you are confident that you can explain that they are absolutely vital. If that is the case, you should write to the other party’s solicitors first setting out the question or questions and why they are vital and ask for the question to be answered voluntarily. Set a deadline for them to confirm it will be answered (say 7 days) and for an answer (day 21 days) and state that you will be making an urgent application to the court if there is no positive response. You could then ask the court to consider the issue in writing and attach the correspondence.

Unfortunately each case is very different, so I cannot say what applies in any particular case without considering the documents and taking full instructions.

If you want to make an appointment, get in touch.

Brexit and Family Law

July 8, 2016

As I’m sitting on a Eurostar train to Brussels, this is a good time to reflect on what Brexit means for family law in England. It is of course important to bear in mind that until the UK actually leaves the EU, all EU law continues to apply in full and even after that, all or some may apply.

There are two main pieces of EU law which are important for family law:

20151226_075810Brussels II: This regulation provides where you can start a divorce in the EU and where you can start proceedings about children. Wherever you have started a court case first, it stays there. So there can be a race to the court. Since English courts apply English law to divorce and financial matters and also to cases about arrangements for children, the outcome of a case in the courts in England can be very different to the outcome in another country. Don’t forget though that the other country may well apply English law to all or some of the aspects of the case. So for example in a recent case the couple are both German and live in England. The husband started a divorce in Germany and the German court applies English law to the divorce itself and also to child and spouse maintenance, but not to the sharing of assets. You need specialist advice on these matters from both (or all) possible countries where a divorce could be started.

For child arrangements the courts of the country where the child is habitually resident usually have jurisdiction. It also makes some additional provisions to strengthen the Hague Convention on Child Abduction for the EU, such as targets to deal with cases in a certain time.

After Brexit, the UK might enter into a treaty with the EU to continue the provisions of Brussels II or it might not. My guess is that it would not want to be seen as a friend of child abductors, so the pressure to enter into an agreement that apply the provisions on children cases to the UK is strong. It is not so strong on the divorce side.

Maintenance: The EU provisions for maintenance regulate where you can start a case and once you have a judgment how to enforce it in another EU country. There is already a treaty to apply very similar provisions to Switzerland, Iceland and Norway, the Lugano Treaty. So on this one, my guess is that Britain might simply become a signatory to the Lugano treaty too.

Aside from the law, and whether or not Brexit is ultimately going to happen, the immediate effect is that we cannot be certain about house prices and that Sterling has seen a drastic drop. So in any financial cases where there are assets in several countries, the comparison of the valuations is going to be difficult: If the parties (and the court) think that the exchange rates are going to recover in the medium to long term, they could take historic exchange rates from earlier in 2016. Unfortunately, since one exchange rate is going to favour one party and another the other party, this could all become contentious. This does, of course, not only affect the Sterling-Euro exchange rate, which was at €1.50 at the end of 2015 and now is below €1.20, a 20% drop, but also the Sterling-US-Dollar exchange rate and any other currency linked to the dollar or Euro in some way. Some parties might want to put financial negotiations on hold until there is certainty.

Where there are assets such as real property or shares where a current valuation is impossible to obtain, it might also be wise to wait unless it is clear an asset will be sold and the proceeds be shared equally. In that case it is just a matter for the parties to agree on the time of sale.

by Andrea Woelke

The Archers – Protecting Helen Titchener

July 6, 2016

As an avid listener of the Archers I have been fascinated by the storyline of the marriage between Rob and Helen. Rob’s abuse of Helen has now culminated in a bloodbath and criminal prosecution.The topic of today’s post is, however, what Helen could have done to protect herself before it came to this.

Storyline summary:

Helen Titchener (née Archer), the daughter of Pat and Tony, was suffering from anorexia when younger and was in a relationship with the former game keeper who then took his own life. She decided she wanted a child when she did not have a partner and had Henry (now 5) by IVF. She formed a relationship with Rob Titchener, who was working at the estate farm and was then still married. He divorced his wife and married Helen, to the astonishment of her family. Rob seems charming and takes everyone in. Over the last year or so, the listener witnessed how he became more and more controlling of Helen and was violent to her. He became ostensibly caring but even more controlling after she told him she was pregnant. He stopped her from working, then from driving, talked behind her back to destroy her friendship with Ian (casually told him that his husband had kissed a colleague and Helen knew), and Helen started doubting her own sanity. Eventually, she confided in her old friend Kirsty who gave Helen a spare mobile phone and put in a number of a domestic abuse helpline.

Helen decided to leave Rob and packed a bag. While cooking dinner in the kitchen, she told Rob and he took a knife and challenged her to kill him as this was the only way she would be able to get rid of him. He then seems to have run past her to get Henry and she took the knife and stabbed Rob.

Rob survived and Helen is now on remand for attempted murder. Henry was staying with Helen’s parents while Rob was in hospital, but Rob failed to return Henry after the first contact and there are now legal proceedings about where Henry should live, while Henry is living with Rob and only sees his maternal grandparents on Sundays. In the meantime Helen has given birth to a baby boy in a mother-and-baby unit of a prison who she has named Jack. Rob wants Jack to live with him (and has given him a different name). Helen has difficulties getting her own story together and giving her lawyers instructions.

IMG-20111001-00007hThe question for me while following the story was what Helen could have done if she had sought legal advice before she left Rob. This is tricky because Rob is good at lying, so good most people believe him and doubt their own senses and sanity. Even judges are regularly taken in by such people as the recent case of Ben Butler jailed for life for murdering his daughter shows. As for Helen Rob seems to have been “gaslighting” her. He seems to have deliberately filled Henry’s bath which Helen was running, with scolding water so that Helen would believe she was losing it, for example. If Helen had left, he would have almost certainly argued she was unfit to look after Helen (and later the then unborn child) and applied for them to live with him (as he is now doing). All the abuse was behind closed doors and it would have been Helen’s (very confused) word against Rob’s (convincing and clear) evidence.

If Helen had come to me I would have firstly considered her own and Henry’s safety, whether the risk to them was such that she had to leave immediately or whether perhaps she could stay to gather evidence. It might have been possible to leave Henry more and more with Helen’s parents using excuses and also get rid of Rob’s mother Ursula (who seems even more manipulative than Rob) by Helen pleading she needed a quiet house during the pregnancy. Helen should always have had an escape plan for immediate help including friends and family who could come and a way to dial 999 to call the police. Should could have talked to the police to make them aware of the situation anyway.

If the risk was too high, I would have advised Helen to leave straight away, but she would have had to be prepared for a lengthy and relentless legal battle over children issues and finances with Rob. She may have been able to mitigate this by going into a women’s refuge, but it is difficult to hide for ever and Rob would have no doubt made applications for contact with Henry, even though he is not his legal father (he apparently has parental responsibility).

If by using some safeguarding measures Helen could have stayed on for a bit, she could have considered how to ensure that there were independent witnesses to the abuse while not provoking Rob to have dangerous outbursts. This is a tricky strategy, but it may have worked. She could, for example, have asked Rob in the village shop for the car keys so other people independent of the family would have witnessed him refusing (or taken the keys so that he would have demanded them from her) etc. Rather than having oral evidence against each other, the only way to win a case against a convincing abuser like Rob is to have external hard evidence, written documents or entirely independent witnesses.

The other strategy, which incidentally Helen’s family should pursue now, is to delve deeper into Rob’s background and anything he did. This could include:
finding out why he suddenly left his job at the estate (he would have been sacked for misconduct) and once this was found out, get witness evidence from the colleagues and research into his previous employment too;

  • find the hunt protester he assaulted a year or so before and see if Shula Hebden-Lloyd will retract her evidence in favour of Rob Titchener which meant he was not charged for the assault (Shula should be aware she might risk a prosecution for perverting the cause of justice);
  • contact the boarding school Rob and Ursula visited and planned to send Henry to behind Helen’s back, check when they contacted the school and how they presented the plans, get this is all in writing and obtain witness statements from the head teacher or admissions officer;
  • contact Rob’s first wife to see if she will give evidence – this will be tainted as Rob will no doubt argue she is just trying to seek revenge – she might, however, have similar compelling independent evidence and could help with contacting previous employers;
  • Rob similarly tried to manipulate Tom, Helen’s brother, by making orders of stock for the farm shop behind his back etc. Tom could ensure that there is a paper (or email) trail for Rob’s behaviour there – again as family, this is not the best evidence;
  • talk to Henry’s school and get details of when exactly he was being difficult or had problems, see if that can be linked to particular behaviour of Rob.
    Overall this would have been a difficult case to put together. No doubt there would have been more examples in real life which one could have looked at. Helen’s and Henry’s safety should always have come first of course.

Clients often ask if they should film their partner so they have proof of the behaviour. The family courts hate this because it seems overly intrusive and harassing in itself. However, at times this might be the only way to have evidence of abuse. This is something Helen should have considered with her solicitor in great detail. If so, cameras could have been installed in the house without Rob noticing and the footage would only be used if absolutely necessary and after Helen was away and safe. This would have required considerable logistical planning.

Staying to gather evidence would have been a risky strategy, not least because Rob’s barrister would have cross-examined Helen and put it to her why she did not leave the abuse and exposed Henry to it if it was that bad. So protecting Henry and her must be the absolute priority in any event.

by Andrea Woelke

The Archers – Anna Tregorran the Lawyer

July 5, 2016

In last night’s Archers (4 July 2016) Anna Tregorran, the barrister representing Helen Titchener confessed to her mother that she was shaken by this case because in the past she failed to protect a client who was then killed by her abusive partner. This is unfortunately not fiction and does happen. It is good to show the human side to our work as family lawyers (even if there is some artistic licence in that there does not seem to be a solicitor), which can be tough going at times.

Unfortunately, abusive partners like Rob Titchener in the Archers sometimes tend to be extremely convincing witnesses and courts are fooled and believe their story instead of the victim’s account. The storyline is fascinating and has given me plenty of food for thought as well as recognition from cases I have dealt with over the years. The most frustrating thing is that here as in real life, we see people getting into a deeper mess because they fail to get legal advice or, when they do, do not act on it. So Pat Archer (Helen’s mother) was told not to talk to the police without consulting Helen’s lawyer. She went off and did and has now become a prosecution witness and must not talk to or even meet her own daughter.

Helen could have taken steps to protect herself and Henry much earlier, although it is often not clear if she would have been strong enough. I will write more about that some other time.

by Andrea Woelke

EU-Certificate for Divorce in England

July 1, 2016

A post in an online forum for Germans in London recently asked how to get the EU-Form after a divorce in England which the German authorities require. The poster was puzzled, as were the courts. Most family courts do not know about this, but can find out and will get the form signed by a judge and sealed if you fill it in.

The EU-Regulation about divorce jurisdiction and recognition, Regulation 2201/2003 has several forms in the Annexes, which – as the whole regulation – are of course available in all official EU languages. The idea is that you get a form sealed in one EU member state and anyone can then retrieve an empty form in their language, lay them side-by-side and check what each of the points say about the parties, date of divorce etc.

In England once you have a decree absolute, you will need to get the relevant form, which you can download and then send it to the family court where your divorce was pronounced and ask them to get it signed by a judge and sealed. I’d suggest to get at least 3 copies because you might need them for various official business. It is free and easy to get immediately after your divorce. It could be a lot more complicated when you need it 10 years later.

by Andrea Woelke

Smartphone Tracking Apps

July 1, 2016

Though your smartphone will give you immediate access to any documents, letters or emails that we send you and will inevitably save time and money, there is also the danger that it is not as secure as you think – and I’m not just talking about your passwords.

man holds iphoneThe rise in connectivity and apps has created a market for apps which are often marketed under the guise of “child safety” but can be used to track the location of the phone, access messages and emails and, in some cases, even listen in via the microphone and camera. What makes these apps dangerous is that they often still work when you think the phone is switched off and, unless you are tech savvy and aware of what should be on your phone, you may not even notice that someone has installed an app without your permission.

I recently came across a case where the former partner knew about someone’s every move and where he had spent the weekend. A tracking app on his phone was the only way that this would have been possible.

Just be aware of the apps that you have installed and of the push-notifications you receive. If you worry that an ex-partner may be tracking you via your smartphone, back up your data manually and restore it to factory settings, ensuring that you download only the apps you trust rather than a full restore like Google and Apple offer.

The best thing is never to let your partner get access to your phone in the first place and always password-protect it. If you are in doubt, special agencies can do a deep clean of your phone for you.

by Andrea Woelke

Hacking

June 30, 2016

One thing often forgotten when you split up from your partner is that they know (or can easily guess) your passwords for your email, Facebook etc. They could also be stored in a cache of a shared computer. Not only could they have advance notice of your communication with your solicitor, but some could cause havoc by “fraping” you (posting things as you on your social media to ridicule or embarrass you in front of friends or family).So one of the first things you should do is to:

1. Change your passwords on all accounts. Use a secure password that cannot be guessed, is unconnected to your favourite holiday place, name, birthdates etc.

2. Clear the browser cache from saved log-in and password details.

3. If in doubt you could consider opening a new web-mail (e.g. gmail) account to use just for communications with your lawyers.

4. Password-protect your mobile phones and make sure you lock them as soon as you put them down. With most phones you can programme a side button to act as a shortcut to lock them.

I have also come across cases where in revenge a former partner destroyed files, photographs, music etc. or kept the joint devices with those things on. It is therefore a good idea to back up all your files, music and photos either on a hard drive you keep away from your home or online (with a secure password of course).

by Andrea Woelke

Heated and Long “Unreasonable Behaviour” Divorce Petitions

June 29, 2016

I saw a client the other day who came with a divorce petition his wife had issued against him after they had recently separated. This contained two pages of allegations of unreasonable behaviour. Leaving aside what if anything of this may have any basis in truth in the particular case, I was quite taken aback that the solicitor had even drafted and issued this petition on behalf of the wife. While I am not privy to the instructions of course, the particulars looked as if the solicitor had simply taken down what the wife had told them and copied it onto the divorce form.

Before going into detail it is important to go back to the law and remind ourselves that the fact is not “unreasonable behaviour”, but (as set out in section 1 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973)  particulars showing:

“that the respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent”

So the behaviour itself does not need to be unreasonable at all. Reasonableness goes to the question of whether future cohabitation can be expected.

So this petitioner, which is not uncommon had a variety of allegations, including:

  • Things the husband was supposed to have done 2 years ago or more. This is irrelevant. The behaviour alleged must be in the six months before separation or, if later, before the petition according to section 2(3).
  • Justifications of the wife’s own behaviour. Again this is totally irrelevant.
  • Issues which are not behaviour, such as communication problems between the parties, the relationship they had with their family etc.
  • An extended narrative of the history of the marriage (moving house and jobs). A brief sentence may in some circumstances be needed to understand an allegation of behaviour, but anything more than that is probably superfluous.
  • Allegations which are unspecific about when they occurred (“recently”). Even if exact dates are not known, it needs to be clear that this was within the six-month period (for example, “at some time in October 2014”).

With behaviour petitions as in so many other legal and non-legal contexts, quantity does not make up for lack of quality.

Nor do courts endorse parties slinging mud against each other. Contested divorces lead to a hearing in public. It rarely happens because the process is complicated and, if the parties are represented, costly. With more people representing themselves, it is likely that they are going to be more frequent. Courts try to discourage them, as in a recent case where a husband (an immigration solicitor it seems) insisted on divorcing his wife on quite salacious allegations including that she offered her services as a prostitute to women on the website Gumtree. If in this case the husband loses the case in the end, he may face having to pay his wife’s legal costs. The judge in the Court of Appeal, Lady Justice Black, pointed out that since they were separated for more than two years and both wanted a divorce, they could agree to withdraw the behaviour petitions and divorce on two years’ separation and consent.

Often clients are unsure what they can use as behaviour. Two points to bear in mind frequently lead to an easy solution:

  • The behaviour does not need to be before the separation, it can be after the separation. Often one or both spouses have found a new partner, whether a serious relationship or on a more casual basis. The only question is whether the petitioner can reasonably be expected to live together in the future, not whether it was reasonable to separate at the time.
  • Any intimate relationship which does not fall into the category of adultery can still be behaviour. This is also helpful for civil partnership dissolutions.

So one solution in many cases, which does not inevitably cause concern for the other spouse is to have a behaviour petition based on the other’s intimate relationship(s) with another man or woman (who does not need to be named) since separation. In fact it is not necessary to specify the gender of the person the respondent had an intimate relationship with.

For help with drafting a petition and divorce in general, please contact us.

by Andrea Woelke